Most coaches assume clients are stuck because they lack awareness, motivation, clarity, or the right strategy. But in many cases, that's not what's actually happening.
In this episode, we break down one of the most misunderstood dynamics in coaching and psychology: secondary gains. These are the hidden, unconscious benefits a client receives from staying in a pattern they consciously say they want to change.
You'll learn why clients can fully understand their behavior and still not change, and why increasing motivation, accountability, or strategy often fails when a deeper psychological function is being met.
We explore how secondary gains show up in coaching containers, including patterns like avoidance, procrastination, emotional withdrawal, perfectionism, and relational resignation as well as why these behaviors persist even when clients are highly self-aware.
You'll also learn how to distinguish between true resistance and protective behavioral payoff, and how to shift your coaching from surface-level intervention into deeper behavioral and nervous system–informed change work.
This episode covers:
-
What secondary gains are in psychology and behavioral science
-
Why clients stay stuck even when they "know better"
-
How protective payoff systems override motivation
-
The difference between resistance and function
-
Why strategy changes fail when underlying needs are unmet
-
How secondary gains show up in real coaching containers
-
A case example of resignation in dating and relational trauma
-
How to help clients meet underlying needs in healthier ways
If you are a coach, therapist, or practitioner who works with clients who "get it but don't do it," this episode will shift how you understand behavior change at a fundamental level.
Apply to The Art and Skill of Coaching: https://calendly.com/jessicademarchis
1-1 Trauma-Informed Coaching: www.chatwithjess.com
Stay in Touch:
www.jessicademarchis.com
IG @jess_demarchis_coaching
