Keshia sits down with Melanie Jackson to work through the confusion left in the wake of The Guardian's exposé on Free Birth Society — what it got right, what it missed, and why neither of them was surprised by it. Drawing on her PhD research and nearly two decades attending home births, Melanie makes a clear distinction between free birth as a personal choice and the newer, more troubling trend of unregulated birth workers stepping into a clinical role they were never trained for. The conversation moves from there into what genuinely informed decision-making looks like, what responsibility actually means once you step outside the maternity care system, and where the middle ground sits between hospital birth and free birth for women chasing a physiological delivery.
In This Episode
Why neither Keshia nor Melanie was surprised by what came out in The Guardian's reporting, and the "cultish" dynamics both had noticed in the free birth community for years
How free birth has shifted from something women arrived at through their own research to something now marketed to them through social media and courses
The difference between free birth (a personal choice) and unregulated birth workers overstepping their scope — and why Melanie sees the latter as the real issue
Why there's no actual research on free birth outcomes, and why that matters for anyone claiming it's either safe or dangerous
What taking on the "red flag waiver" role really requires — full clinical knowledge, an emergency plan, and honest capacity to make decisions mid-labour
The unspoken burden placed on partners who may not be prepared to become the emergency responder if something goes wrong
Doulas vs. unregulated birth workers vs. midwives — where the boundaries should sit, and why crossing them creates the grey area fuelling most bad outcomes
Melanie's own PhD research and why she pushes back on "you can't talk about free birth if you haven't done it"
A spectrum of options for a physiological birth short of free birth: private home birth midwives, publicly funded home birth programs, midwifery group practice, birth centres, and doula support
Rapid-fire listener questions: are C-sections really "safer" than vaginal birth, is VBAC possible after multiple caesareans, and is going past 41–42 weeks gestation an actual risk
Melanie's longest supported pregnancy — 43 weeks and 1 day — and what that birth taught her client
Where to Find Melanie
melaniethemidwife.com
The Great Birth Rebellion podcast
Annual "Convergence of Rebellious Midwives" conference (Melbourne this year)
Upcoming book: Guide to a Great Pregnancy (with a follow-up on birth to come)
This Episode is Brought to you by INBLUEM
Enjoy 10% off your order with the code RETURNTOWISDOMPODCAST at
Podden och tillhörande omslagsbild på den här sidan tillhör
Keshia Tognazzini. Innehållet i podden är skapat av Keshia Tognazzini och inte av,
eller tillsammans med, Poddtoppen.
