Send us Fan Mail
AI recruiting for nonprofits can help teams manage a mountain of applications, but a polished résumé still leaves one big question: can this person do the work? Dana Scurlock, Managing Director of Staffing Boutique, explores smarter screening, candidate transparency, and hiring practices that keep human judgment in the process.
Joining Julia C. Patrick and Sherry Quam Taylor, Dana considers a hiring puzzle that deserves a seat at your next leadership meeting: employers want candidates who can use AI, yet still need to understand what those candidates can contribute themselves.
That résumé might sparkle. The interview still has a job to do.
“AI is not a replacement for the human portion of recruiting and hiring, and it shouldn't be looked at as such,” Dana begins.
She describes recruiting situations where a single job posting brings hundreds of résumés, making screening efficiency a real operational concern. Applicant tracking systems (ATS) help organize candidate information, and AI-assisted screening raises questions about keywords, access, and who advances.
For nonprofit hiring managers balancing recruitment with an already-full workload, the discussion connects technology choices to staff capacity, candidate experience, and the quality of hiring decisions.
The conversation also moves beyond résumé screening into AI interviews and hiring assessments. If candidates will use AI on the job, how should that affect the assignments used to evaluate them? What should employers disclose and what should applicants explain about their own AI use?
Discover why even relationship-centered fundraising roles increasingly involve technology, how résumé optimization can signal a willingness to learn, and why impressive presentation deserves a closer look at actual capability.
Dana’s recommendation for nonprofit leaders: develop employee guidelines that explain where AI belongs, where human judgment matters, and what your organization expects.
Key Takeaways:
- Use AI to support screening while retaining human evaluation.
- Assess demonstrated ability beyond résumé polish and keywords.
- Disclose when candidates are interacting with AI.
- Set clear AI-use expectations before hiring assessments.
- Define organizational boundaries for AI in employee guidelines.
00:00:00 AI Recruiting and Nonprofit Hiring
00:03:29 AI Skills Are Appearing in Job Descriptions
00:06:57 Nonprofit Employers Weigh Efficiency and Ethics
00:08:04 Keeping Human Judgment in Recruiting
00:10:53 Applicant Tracking Systems and Résumé Screening
00:12:11 Keywords, Candidate Access, and Technology Skills
00:14:19 Why Fundraising Roles Need AI Fluency
00:15:58 What AI-Ready Résumés Signal to Hiring Managers
00:18:24 Transparency in AI Screening and Interviews
00:20:20 Setting AI Rules for Hiring Assessments
00:22:23 Evaluating Capability Beyond a Polished Application
00:25:37 Employee AI Guidelines and Human Judgment
#TheNonprofitShow #NonprofitHiring #AIRecruiting
Find us Live daily on YouTube!
Find us Live daily on LinkedIn!
Find us Live daily on X: @Nonprofit_Show
Our national co-hosts and amazing guests discuss management, money and missions of nonprofits!
12:30pm ET 11:30am CT 10:30am MT 9:30am PT
Send us your ideas for Show Guests or Topics: HelpDesk@AmericanNonprofitAcademy.com
Visit us on the web:The Nonprofit Show
