Over two decades in Memphis-area schools will teach you how to spot a leader who's still growing. Fred Holmes — known inside the Ruckus Maker Mastermind as the Velvet Hammer — started as a science teacher in Shelby County Schools, moved through teacher leadership and an assistant principalship, ran his own building as principal in Arkansas, and is now back in Memphis Shelby County Schools as a Professional Learning Communities coach, building leadership capacity district-wide. He's been a Ruckus Maker since the Mastermind's earliest days, joining during his first principalship and never missing a Wednesday since. Find him inside the Ruckus Maker community at betterleadersbetterschools.com
Most AI tools will give you a confident answer whether or not it's actually true. Fred Holmes, a longtime Ruckus Maker and Memphis-area school leader, breaks down why he trusts his AI coach for principals — Digital Danny, built exclusively for school leadership — with his highest-stakes conversations, and why a decade-old peer Mastermind still shapes how he leads today.
🖊️ What You'll Learn
- Why generic AI tools like ChatGPT and Gemini can't replace a coach trained specifically for school leadership.
- How Fred rehearses high-stakes conversations with his AI coach before he has them in real life.
- The four jobs a real AI coach for principals should actually do.
- Why Fred still shows up to the same Wednesday Mastermind after nearly a decade.
- How to use your commute to get mentally ready to lead, instead of scrolling.
🔨 Breaking Down the Old Rules 🫶 Key Insight #1: Why Generic AI Tools Fail as an AI Coach for Principals
- What's broken: Tools like ChatGPT and Gemini answer every question with total confidence — even when they don't actually know — because they're trained on everyone's data instead of built for school leadership.
- The shift: An AI coach for principals should be trained exclusively on real school leadership coaching, refuse to train on your private conversations, and say "I don't know" instead of guessing.
- Impact: Fred trusts it enough to bring real, sensitive workplace situations to it — the kind he'd never run through a general AI tool.
🧲 Key Insight #2: How to Rehearse a High-Stakes Conversation Before You Have It
- What's broken: Principals walk into tough conversations — an underperforming direct report, a political conflict with a supervisor, a hard parent call — without a sounding board, and the wrong tone can make everything worse.
- The shift: Fred talks through the exact conversation with his AI coach first, testing language and thinking through the other person's perspective before he ever says a word out loud.
- Impact: He shows up calm and confident, because he's already rehearsed the hardest part before it happens.
🚀 Key Insight #3: Why an AI Coach Still Can't Replace a Weekly Peer Mastermind
- What's broken: Isolated leaders assume an always-on AI tool is enough support — but the loneliness of leadership doesn't disappear because there's an app on your phone.
- The shift: Fred pairs his AI coach with a live, weekly Mastermind of peer principals, using one as a thought partner and the other as human accountability.
- Impact: Nearly a decade later, he still hasn't missed a Wednesday.
💡 FRED HOLMES QUOTES FROM THE RUCKUSCAST
"It's refreshing, it's renewing, it's empowering. It's where the loneliness of leadership disappears."
— Fred Holmes
"I already know where this is going. He's going to say, put it on the calendar."
— Fred Holmes
"Digital Danny just cuts through that noise, gives the signal."
— Fred Holmes
"I have this calmness and this peace. But also I have the confidence because I had that conversation."
— Fred Holmes
"If you're getting better, then your school is going to get better."
— Fred Holmes
♟Your Do School Different Challenge
Ready to implement? Start here:
- Tomorrow: Open your AI coach — or a blank doc if you don't have one yet — and talk through the one high-stakes conversation you've been avoiding this week.
- This Month: Build a 10-minute reflection or coaching routine into your commute instead of starting your day on your phone.
- This Semester: Find or start a weekly peer Mastermind where other leaders push you the way Fred's Wednesday group pushes him.
⌚️ Episode Timestamps
- 00:00 - Why Fred never misses a Wednesday Mastermind
- 04:57 - Fred's journey to Memphis PLC coach
- 06:16 - Why Digital Danny was a level up
- 08:31 - The four jobs Digital Danny does for principals
- 11:01 - How Fred uses Digital Danny every morning
- 14:40 - Using Digital Danny before tough conversations
- 18:17 - What surprised Fred most about the tool
- 22:00 - Why Fred trusts Digital Danny over ChatGPT
- 25:18 - Inside the private Ruckus Maker Club
- 33:16 - The legacy behind the Ruckus Makers community
- 34:29 - How Fred found Mastermind through Google
- 37:53 - Fred's parting advice to Ruckus Makers
🔗 Connect With Fred Holmes
📝 Read trascript here
🌍 Website: https://betterleadersbetterschools.com/
🔗 LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/frederick-holmes-carpediem/
🎧 Listen & Subscribe
Listen to Better Leaders Better Schools on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Youtube or wherever you get your podcasts. If today's episode moved you, leave a review — it helps more Ruckus Makers find the show.
🧔🏻♂️ Your SelfMentorship Guide
Meet Digital Danny — your SelfMentorship guide. Always available, never forgets, and evolves with you. Think through your next leadership move at myprincipalcoach.com
Today's Ruckuscast Partners
Orchard gives every student an actual career-readiness score — a real number you can hand your board instead of a vague hope. It's built by a founder who watched his own dad drift through a career he hated and decided kids deserve better than that.
🔎 See what Orchard built at BetterLeadersOrchardCareers.com
ODP Business Solutions has spent 30 years turning ordinary campuses into learning environments students actually want to be in — furniture, tech integration, and sustainable builds, all from a single supplier so procurement isn't a nightmare. They helped Belago Academy build collaborative spaces so engaging students forgot to check their phones.
🔎 Start at ODPbusiness.com/education
IXL's universal screener identifies which students need intervention in 20 minutes or less, then its adaptive platform adjusts to the right difficulty for every single student automatically. Over a million teachers already trust it to make differentiated instruction possible without adding hours to their week.
🔎 Get started at IXL.com/leaders
Kids First Education exists to put the reason you became a leader — the kids — back at the center of your job, with coaching and support built specifically for school and district leaders. 98% of educators who work with them say they left ready to use what they learned that same week.
Learn more at KidsFirstLLC.com/leaders
