A few years ago, the sociologist Yingyi Ma asked hundreds of Chinese undergraduates in the United States what they had crossed an ocean to find. The same phrase kept coming back: critical thinking. One student called it the crown jewel of an American education.
This episode approaches that question from the other end. Yuki Yu Wei, as currently a geopolitical analyst, spent two years inside a Chinese university before transferring to the University of Colorado Denver. Now, she has finished a degree in political science and communication, and open to collaborations, as well as analyst or journalist position, as next step of her intellectual journey.
In our conversation, Yuki has shared many of her own stories, along with insightful and thoughtful perception on them. Some of her experience align with Ma’s points, some sharply against them, which brought the image of Chinese student beyond statistic points in research report.
What Yuki offered was more than agreement or disagreement. Her central move is to take the mystique out of critical thinking. It is not, she argues, a teaching technique that American classrooms happen to have perfected and that travels neatly in a suitcase. Instead, it is a permission, a permission to hold a perspective, to not produce the one correct answer, to question the authority standing at the front of the room. And the part I keep returning to: Real critical thinking begins not in argument but in listening. The aim is not to win the other person over. It is to learn their reality.
From there the conversation widens. We talk about the Chinese classroom as a kind of theater, where bodies are present, but attention has quietly left the room, held together by an unspoken contract that lets teachers perform teaching and students perform listening. Most of time, this was read as the teacher’s laziness that renders a mundane classroom. In this podcast, we elevated this discussion into structural level. Instead of laziness, we believe it’s better to read as teacher’s insecurity. We have discussed how a test-fixed system, whose behavioral inertia, runs from the first grade all the way into the research-funded university, and finally causes the inefficiency in classroom. And we also discussed the self-censorship happens in classroom conversation in China, and how that extend to a cognitive habit frequently observed from Chinese public argument: the reflex to hand down a verdict where a derivation belongs, to reach for a moral judgment instead of reconstructing who and what actually produced an outcome.
If there is a discipline running underneath all of this, it is the opposite of the easy verdict. Neither of us is interested in treating a system’s dysfunctions as proof of its repression, or in folding a complicated society into a single word. The harder and more useful task is to trace specific mechanisms —how a given structure forms, what it asks of the people living inside it, and why it yields the outcomes it does. That is criticism in the service of understanding, and of a transition that is still very much in motion.
Below, you’ll find Yuki’s own site – Atlaspedia.
Yuki has been dedicated in long form analysis articles covers topic in geo-economic, post-colonial study, and gender politics. She believes the importance on translating not just between language, but also frameworks. To achieve that, it’s necessary to think outside of right-or-wrong judgement. But to have ability to trace back to each component that contributed the current status. (non-biased)
Two pieces of hers that put this method to work:
Her essay on the Gen Z divination craze. Here, she discussed the Chinese Gen-Z’s over-dependency on psychic and fortune tellers. Her investigation reveals the collective dilemma causes by insufficient social support from government, job market, and education system. And such insufficiency, as Yuki defined, rooted from the compressed modernization process in China – where economic speed forward, but protective infrastructure was not established correspondingly. See: Do You Still Go to Your Teacher When Having Problems? : China’s Gen Z Divination Craze and the Deep Crisis of the Grand Narrative Beneath the Chinese Educational System
The “Goose Leg Auntie” affair. With deep investigation on Chinese state and social governance, examines how Chinese school education extend to an insufficiency of social governance, and resulted a food-safety problem being left unreported for years. She proposed the concept “layered transition”. This concept helps to bring under-examined historical factors into discussion, allows analysis focus on real problems and cause within Chinese social structure, without fallout on bias. See: The Commodification of the Labor Heroism Narrative: Structural Fault Lines in Chinese Social Governance
*A note on the 夏美 (Xiamei) case
Xiamei is a Chinese short-video influencer who, over roughly 2014–2020, did risqué modeling in an online grey market — work she took up at seventeen after a Shanghai girl group she’d joined fell apart. She later remade herself on Douyin as a “self-made woman” figure, telling young women to invest in study and skills rather than trade on their looks. In late May 2026 her old photos resurfaced, colliding with that inspirational persona and igniting a nationwide argument. In her own response she didn’t deny the past, framed it as a survival choice made young, and again urged young women toward education over shortcuts.
Opinion split hard. Some defended her right to change and warned against pinning a person to their past forever; others held that packaging years of edge-content into an inspirational brand could mislead younger followers. The strand Yuki picks up is a third move: critics who treated her mentioning the grey industry as advocating for it, and demanded a performative self-condemnation. That slide — from naming a subject to endorsing it, and from individual choice to structural blame — is the same reflex she traces back to how sensitive topics get handled in the Chinese classroom.
Get full access to New China Literacy at yaqil.substack.com/subscribe
