Send us Fan Mail

In the Season 1 Finale of Case Files After Crime, we examine one of the most disturbing and unresolved cases connected to New Jersey.

Celina Mays was just 12 years old- and nine months pregnant - when she disappeared from her home in Willingboro, New Jersey, in December 1996.  She was last seen inside a residence tied to a close knit religious community - a place where she should have been safe.

Then she was gone.

There were no signs of a struggle.  No clear evidence of where she went.  And despite years of investigation, Celina Mays has never been found.

Her case raises difficult questions - about what happened inside that home, who may have been involved, and how a disappearance like this could go unanswered for so long. 

More than two decades later, the mystery remains.

This is Case File 008 - Echoes in the Church.

Listen now to the Season 1 Finale of Case Files After Crime.

Season 1A ends here...but the investigation continues in Season 1B.

Podden och tillhörande omslagsbild på den här sidan tillhör Meeah. Innehållet i podden är skapat av Meeah och inte av, eller tillsammans med, Poddtoppen.