Nicole sits down with Caitlin Pyle to explore her unconventional path from freelance proofreader to deconstruction advocate, community builder, and documentary producer. Caitlin shares how healing, spirituality, and her lived experience with mental health and evangelical Christianity shaped the work she does now, including her mission to help people reclaim inner authority and move from fear toward love. It’s a deeply candid conversation about identity, freedom, and what it means to build a meaningful life on your own terms.
Host: Nicole Spencer
Guest: Caitlin Pyle
Executive Producers:
Glenn Milley
and
Bessie Fong
New episodes air every Tuesday. Be sure to subscribe and leave a review!
Join us on this spiritual journey by staying connected:
Watch all episodes on YouTube
Follow on Instagram
and
TikTok
Join Nicole’s Substack
Who should Nicole interview next? Share your thoughts with us at
hello@spiritualityforskeptics.com
ABOUT THE GUEST:
Caitlin Pyle is a certified professional coach, mentor, and spiritual commentator who spent 15 years steeped in evangelicalism. Severe mental health struggles forced her into deconstruction and a total unraveling of her former life. Now, she shines a bright light on the unhealthy beliefs and doctrines that fuel anxiety and depression for so many, showing that true freedom exists on the other side of fear. Caitlin is also the Executive Producer of the upcoming documentary, Mental Hell, which examines modern evangelical Christianity and its effects on mental health.
https://selftransformation.com/
https://www.youtube.com/@CaitlinPyle
https://www.tiktok.com/@thecaitawakening
https://www.facebook.com/Caitlin87/
ABOUT THE HOST:
Nicole Spencer is the host and curator of Spirituality for Skeptics, a show that explores the shift from doubt to belief through raw, transformative conversations. Raised without spirituality or religion, she never expected to find herself on this path. In her mid-30s, mentors and personal experiences opened her to curiosity about the unseen, inspiring her to create a space where others could explore freely without dogma or prescription.
Before launching the show, Nicole built and sold two coaching companies at different stages of her career. Most recently, she scaled a business coaching brand to 8-figures in six years, generating over $13 million in that time. The success was rewarding and she remains grateful for it, but even at the height of achievement she sensed there was something more. Stepping away, she turned her focus to the deeper pursuit of peace, fulfillment, and meaning.
Through unpolished, emotionally honest stories, Spirituality for Skeptics offers a rare space for those who doubt but long to believe.
