Continuing our summer read-along of Life at the Speed of Play by Mark Pincus, this week’s chapter goes after a term most of us in product have used without question for twenty years: MVP. Pincus’s argument is that the word “viable” is the problem. It’s become an excuse to overinvest before you’ve ever learned anything, when the actual odds that your first version succeeds are close to zero anyway.
Confessions of a Creative Leader is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
What you’ll learn:
* Pincus’s replacement for MVP: the “minimum idea state” (MIS), just enough of an idea (a text link, a slide, a vibe-coded demo that breaks after ten clicks) to get real directional feedback before you’ve built anything. I connected this to a concept my friend Josh Barker writes about in his book on finding market traction, the “minimum viable solution,” which is the same idea wearing a different name
* The “rip-o-matic,” borrowed from how movie trailers convey tone before production starts. This is basically what my team just did two days ago in a Foundation Sprint: a full day identifying the problem and who it’s for, then a second day sketching out competing approaches with a catchy pitch and a doodle, no prototyping, before ever agreeing on what to test
* Pincus’s line that stuck with me: “if you’re not embarrassed, you’re not launching early enough.” As someone currently building and launching a product in real time, that one landed
* Emmett Shear’s more radical idea, referenced in the chapter: don’t start with an idea at all. Use data to generate the idea instead of using the idea to generate data, because the moment you show someone your idea and ask them to critique it, your ego is already tied to being right. This is close to how Continuous Discovery Habits by Teresa Torres has shaped how we actually build at Watermark, just talking to people with no agenda, well before there’s an idea to defend
* The shift from MVP to “maximum product launch.” The whole point of testing small and raw is to earn the conviction to go big once you’ve actually found true signal, not before
Confessions of a Creative Leader is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Get full access to Confessions of a Creative Leader at creativeleaderconfessions.substack.com/subscribe
