Is AI Writing Broken Software? | Shop Talk EP101

Could AI rescue your favourite discontinued software—or recreate an application you already use? And how would you know the result actually works?This week on Shop Talk, Dave and Glen tackle your questions about AI software cloning, reverse engineering, and the difference between a convincing demonstration and a program you can trust. We discuss testing, readable code, ongoing maintenance, software ownership, and the uncomfortable questions about copying someone else’s work.We also explore practical AI workflows: writing specifications, having one AI review another’s work, and keeping a project from turning into a spaghetti monster. Plus, Gary and BSD, connecting modern hardware to old computers, Colossal Cave, Excel Easter eggs, and BBS memories.Finally, we put three viewer suggestions to Dave: an AI project walkthrough, NightDriver’s architecture, and old computers working with new hardware.

00:00 - Start00:37 - Can AI Rescue Old Software?04:02 - Recovering Your Own Programs04:34 - Who Maintains the AI Rebuild?06:39 - New Drivers for Old Hardware07:08 - Can Two AIs Make a Clean Room?07:54 - What Could the Agent Access?09:09 - What Did the Other Project Do?11:49 - Where Does ReactOS Fit?12:57 - Does a Clone Copy the Bugs?15:00 - Who Tests the AI?15:26 - Testing the Failure Paths16:09 - How Do You Trust AI Output?20:01 - Can Humans Maintain the Code?20:59 - Could the Clone Be Malicious?22:08 - What Did It Cost?24:06 - Dave’s Actual AI Toolchain25:19 - Why Rust?25:51 - The Training-Data Double Standard29:15 - Would Restrictions Block Competition?30:25 - Who Pays for Original Software?32:44 - Rebuilding One Feature for Yourself33:54 - Will Your License Outlive the Server?34:52 - One AI Reviews Another35:51 - From Specification to Working Code37:40 - Keeping AI Project History39:35 - AI Reads the Event Logs40:30 - Coding for a Mechanical Mind42:25 - A Viewer Builds a Windows Tool43:24 - Did the Boards Work?43:55 - Modern Help for Old Computers44:40 - What Is BSD?45:34 - Gary Teaches a Viewer UNIX46:07 - Speech on a PDP-11?46:39 - The Colossal Cave Follow-Up47:34 - TMOG Column Selection48:17 - Which Process Uses the Network?49:01 - Would AI Find the Easter Egg?49:52 - Dave’s BBS Days50:38 - A Live Shop Talk?52:33 - A: From AI Spec to Software52:47 - B: Inside NightDriver53:12 - C: Old Computers, New Hardware54:29 - Sound issues, Dave tells a joke and Dave’s new desk!56:21 - The Friendly Coder….