In this episode of Cinema Callback, Andy and Michael dive deep into the 2024 horror sensation Longlegs, discussing whether Osgood Perkins’ latest nightmare is a genuine modern classic or a case of “all style, no substance.” Through the show’s signature voice note format, the conversation unfolds as they debate one of the most divisive horror films of recent years — a movie surrounded by mystery, viral marketing, and massive expectations.
Across their back-and-forth voice notes, Andy and Michael examine the film’s striking visuals, unsettling atmosphere, and the question of whether its “shroud of danger and dread” is enough to carry a story that some viewers have described as lacking substance. They explore the incredible cinematography, the influence of 70s rock aesthetics, and the strange connection between the film’s satanic imagery and the music of Mark Bolan and T. Rex.
The discussion also turns to Nicolas Cage’s unforgettable performance as the bizarre and terrifying Longlegs. Is Cage delivering a genuinely disturbing transformation into a grotesque dollmaker, or does the character’s appearance and mannerisms distract from the horror by feeling closer to a surreal parody? Andy and Michael debate whether the performance becomes the film’s greatest strength or its biggest distraction.
They also look at the genius of the film’s marketing campaign, which built anticipation through a mysterious, Blair Witch-style approach and helped create the idea that audiences were about to experience something truly “bananas.” But does Longlegs live up to the hype? Is it a worthy successor to films like The Silence of the Lambs, or is it more like a “non-alcoholic beer” — something that looks and feels right but lacks the final kick?
Join Andy and Michael as they leave a message after the beep for a spoiler-filled deep dive into Longlegs, exploring dolls, psychics, the “downstairs man,” and whether this horror phenomenon truly delivers on its terrifying promise.
Warning: This episode contains full spoilers for Longlegs. Listen at your own risk.
