Fresh from their marathon livestream watchalong of the 2026 Emmys, Katey and Chris — live from their Toronto Airbnb! — recap the highlights and lowlights of the night, from Allison Janney's delightful shock and the Widow's Bay sweep to the bad production choices that led to literal awkward silence onstage. For much more on the night, revisit our livestream on YouTube.
00:00 Intro
00:11 Live From Toronto After The Emmys
00:44 Widow's Bay Sweeps The Night
03:05 Hacks' Disappointing Farewell
04:57 Apple's Comedy Stranglehold
05:54 The Pitt's Divided Victory
10:45 Pluribus And Vince Gilligan's First Emmy
12:38 Beef Flops, Sally Field Surprises
14:32 The Categories They Cut
16:04 How The Broadcast Ran Short
17:59 The In Memoriam Done Right
20:27 McConaughey And Harrelson's Endless Bit
22:14 What We've Done At TIFF
25:28 What's Coming Next Season
Subscribe today to Prestige Junkie After Party bonus episodes.
Subscribe to the Prestige Junkie newsletter.
Follow Katey on Letterboxd.
Follow The Ankler.
