Mathias Kiwanuka and Barry Cofield gave the Giants two legitimate championship contributors, but the rest of the 2006 draft class delivered almost no lasting value. The Giants gained two dependable defensive starters while sacrificing too many opportunities throughout the remaining rounds.
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
Did Mathias Kiwanuka and Barry Cofield save the Giants’ 2006 draft class? No—the two defensive hits helped build championship teams, but they could not erase the lack of production from nearly every other selection.
Before revisiting the draft, Drew and Rob react to Thomas Fidone II, Sam Roberts and Roy Robertson-Harris opening training camp on the PUP list. Fidone is recovering from offseason foot surgery, Roberts underwent an undisclosed procedure, and Robertson-Harris continues working back from a torn Achilles. The concern level is different for each player, with Roberts carrying the clearest chance to earn a meaningful defensive role this season.
Then the focus shifts to the 2006 draft, beginning with Kiwanuka. The final pick of the first round spent his entire nine-year career with the Giants, moved between defensive end and linebacker, recorded 38.5 sacks and earned two Super Bowl rings. Injuries interrupted parts of his career—including the fractured fibula that kept him out of the Super Bowl XLII run—but he remained one of the few dependable pieces from the class.
Was Sinorice Moss one of the biggest missed opportunities of the draft?
The Giants used the 44th overall pick on Moss, hoping his speed would create an explosive offensive weapon. Instead, injuries and limited production held him to 39 receptions, 421 yards and three touchdowns during his Giants career. Gerris Wilkinson became primarily a reserve linebacker and special-teams contributor, while Guy Whimper eventually developed into a starting offensive tackle only after leaving New York.
Barry Cofield became the one major value pick. Selected in the fourth round, he immediately entered the starting lineup, helped anchor the defensive front during the Super Bowl XLII season and later produced several productive years in Washington. His career made him the clearest example of the type of mid-round value the Giants failed to find elsewhere in the class.
Charlie Peprah never played a regular-season snap for the Giants after being waived during final cuts, but he later became a Super Bowl champion and productive starter with Green Bay. Gerrick McPhearson never appeared in an NFL game.
The final verdict is blunt: the Giants found two players they liked, but that was not enough. Kiwanuka and Cofield made the class memorable, yet the volume of misses made the 2006 draft a failure overall.
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show
