He was raised as a third-generation Jehovah's Witness, with his entire family inside the organization. His stepfather was an elder. Leaving meant losing everything — and he knew it from age 12.
Today, Dr. Cary is a theology professor at Walsh University, and a devoted Catholic. And in this episode, he pulls back the curtain on everything.
What do Jehovah's Witnesses actually believe about Jesus, the Holy Spirit, heaven, and hell? Why is it a cult — and how can you tell? What happens when you leave? And what should you say if one comes to your door?
This is one of the most eye-opening conversations we've ever had on this show. In this episode:
- What Jehovah's Witnesses believe about Jesus (it's not what you'd expect)
- The 144,000 — and what they believe happens to everyone else
- How the organization uses isolation and shunning to control members
- What "PIMO" means — and why thousands are secretly trapped inside
- Practical tips for talking to a Jehovah's Witness at your door
- The moment at age 12 that started Dr. Cary's journey out
- How a funeral homily reignited his wife's faith — and changed his life
- The first Mass that broke him open and brought him home
HIGHLIGHTS
0:00 — Introduction
2:00 — What Jehovah's Witnesses actually believe about Jesus, the Trinity, and the Holy Spirit
10:54 — What it's like growing up inside the organization: fear, conditional love, and a judgmental God
18:12 — Why Jehovah's Witnesses are a cult: isolation, shunning, and what happened when Dr. Cary left his family 23:20 — Leadership structure, the Governing Body, and the Watchtower Society explained
30:30 — What to say when a Jehovah's Witness comes to your door
38:39 — Dr. Cary's "Cornelius moment": the 12-year-old boy named John whose death changed everything
49:50 — Eight years of weekly invitations — and the Sunday Dr. Cary finally said yes to Mass
.......
Sign up for The Daily Anchor to get Chris Stefanick's bite-sized reflections every morning and be entered for a chance to win a trip for two on our Pilgrimage to Beauty: https://bit.ly/4tQCXtP
........
Support the creation of this content by becoming a Missionary of Joy with a monthly gift to Real Life Catholic and get free access to 9 transformative courses: https://bit.ly/4nTHbN0
........
The Chris Stefanick Show will soon be premiering on EWTN+ Streaming! You can start watching more great content at: EWTN.com/ondemand/
Chapters
- (00:00:00) - Converting From Jehovah's Witness to Catholic
- (00:02:35) - Jehovah's Witnesses: Explained From The Inside
- (00:07:51) - St. Michael and Jesus: Do They Really Be The Same Person
- (00:10:10) - Daily Inspiration
- (00:10:50) - Jehovah's Witnesses: What Was It Like Growing Up
- (00:18:05) - Jehovah's Witnesses: Is It a Cult?
- (00:23:19) - Jehovah's Witnesses: Leadership Structure
- (00:28:25) - Jehovah's Witnesses: Are You Active?
- (00:30:14) - Jehovah's Witnesses
- (00:35:41) - Jehovah's Witnesses: Are They Real?
- (00:37:17) - The Catholic Church's shunning
- (00:38:32) - Jehovah's Witness: My Cornelius Moment
- (00:43:29) - Jehovah's Witness who left the faith
- (00:49:16) - One Catholic man's emotional spiritual conversion
- (00:53:15) - The Faith of Academic Work
- (00:53:32) - Jehovah's Witness At Mass
