Send us Fan Mail
Behavioral science for nonprofit fundraising reveals why good intentions do not always become donations and how nonprofits can design a donor experience that makes giving easier, more confident, and more rewarding. Eleni Fischer and Julia Toffoli of ideas42 share research-informed strategies for reducing donor friction without manufacturing or manipulating generosity.
Donors operate in an increasingly crowded environment filled with emails, text messages, online appeals, giving platforms, and nearly two million registered U.S. nonprofits. Even people who genuinely want to give can become overwhelmed by competing choices, limited attention, unclear information, and a lack of meaningful feedback!
In this conversation, Eleni and Julia explain how behavioral science examines the way people actually make decisions, not how organizations assume they should behave. Donors rely on emotions, habits, social norms, context, and mental shortcuts, especially when the number of choices becomes difficult to manage.
That creates an important operational challenge for nonprofit leaders: fundraising success depends on more than producing another appeal or asking development staff to make more phone calls. The complete donor journey must be considered, including discovery, website design, donation forms, communications, stewardship, personalization, and reporting.
Julia explains, “We don’t want to try to manufacture intent or get people to do something that they don’t want to do.” Instead, the goal is to help donors follow through on generosity they already value.
The guests introduce ideas42’s ‘Generosity by Design’ framework, organized around four areas: capturing attention and encouraging discovery, curating and personalizing choices, improving framing and choice architecture, and providing reflection and feedback.
As Julia reminds nonprofit teams, “Everything is a design choice.” When fundraising, marketing, technology, leadership, and donor services work together, nonprofits can create giving experiences that feel less transactional and more meaningful without adding unreasonable demands to already limited staff capacity.
Key Takeaways:
Choice overload can delay giving and reduce satisfaction with the final decision.
Curated recommendations can help donors navigate an enormous field of charitable options.
Donation-page design influences donor confidence, completion, and satisfaction.
Feedback about giving history and impact can reinforce future generosity.
Behavioral science should inform marketing, technology, stewardship, and fundraising—not remain isolated within one department.
Nonprofits should help donors fulfill existing intentions rather than attempt to manufacture them.
00:00:00 Unlocking Generosity with Behavioral Science
00:02:11 How ideas42 Applies Behavioral Science
00:05:09 How Donors Actually Make Decisions
00:07:47 Donor Attention in an Overwhelming World
00:09:42 Psychology, Culture, and Charitable Giving
00:12:18 Redesigning the Donation Experience
00:13:19 Turning Fundraiser Intuition into Strategy
00:14:33 Aligning Fundraising, Marketing, and Technology
00:18:51 The Biggest Behavioral Barriers to Giving
00:21:59 Introducing Generosity by Design
00:23:36 Curation, Personalization, and Choice Architecture
00:24:58 Why Donors Need Reflection and Feedback
#NonprofitFundraising #DonorEngagement #TheNonprofitShow
Find us Live daily on YouTube!
Find us Live daily on LinkedIn!
Find us Live daily on X: @Nonprofit_Show
Our national co-hosts and amazing guests discuss management, money and missions of nonprofits!
12:30pm ET 11:30am CT 10:30am MT 9:30am PT
Send us your ideas for Show Guests or Topics: HelpDesk@AmericanNonprofitAcademy.com
Visit us on the web:The Nonprofit Show
