Three girls left a Halloween party in Akron, New York, in 1890. Only one of them came home.
Sadie McMullen was just 17 when she was accused of throwing two young girls from a railroad trestle into Murder Creek. But the story gets even stranger from there. Sadie claimed she couldn't remember what happened, and at her trial, her family described years of seizures, blackouts, strange behavior, and mental illness. The jury ultimately found her not guilty by reason of insanity, and she was sent to the Buffalo State Asylum.
But Sadie's story is only one of the legends surrounding Murder Creek. Long before her case, another story claimed the creek earned its grim name after a romantic tragedy involving a Seneca woman, her lover, and a man who wanted her for himself.
So what actually happened at Murder Creek? And how much of either story can we really trust? This episode offers a look into the Victorian era’s treatment of women, mental illness, and sensationalized journalism. Together, these stories reveal how folklore and historical bias can shape the way a place is remembered.
https://citegeistpod.com/
Have a ghost story you want to share? Leave a voice note or send an en email at https://citegeistpod.com/contact
Podcast Instagram: http://instagram.com/citegeistpod
Personal Instagram: http://instagram.com/joshua.spellman
Channel illustration by
GiAnna Ligammari: https://virtualgia.com/
GiAnna's Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/virtualgia.zip
Royalty Free Music: "Behind the Veil" by 8er41
Sources
“Akron Falls County Park.” Upstate NY Photography, Waterfalls, Nature, n.d. Accessed November 14, 2020. https://nyfalls.com/waterfalls/akron-falls/.
Buffalo Courier Express (Buffalo, New York). “Finds Murder Creek’s Name.” May 2, 1926.
Buffalo Patriot and Commercial Advertiser (Buffalo, New York). “Hands Wanted.” September 14, 1813.
Cummings, Uriah. The Haunted Corners. 1906. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1se4i9cBSJ-dZGI-ibb7Uue8CKuBypSvb/view?usp=sharingI&fbclid=IwY2xjawUjp-xleHRuA2FlbQIxMQBwZG9mBXNydGMGYXBwX2lkEDIyMjAzOTE3ODgyMDA4OTIAAR7tB49DahyNZjVnPKDOSM1pBHbJMJjXeoEvotV3yrovvIjSHFsR3URN1zvi8g_aem_XMMtRrJSO-WCr0Vkj_2-pA&usp=embed_facebook.
“Ellen May ‘Nellie’ Connor (1880-1890) - Find A...” Accessed November 14, 2020. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/117793906/ellen-may-connor.
Ellicott, Joseph &. B. Map of Morris’s Purchase or West Geneseo In the State of New York. 1804. https://www.davidrumsey.com/luna/servlet/detail/RUMSEY~8~1~1808~180026:Map-of-Morris-s-Purchase-or-West-Ge.
Estephe, St. “Unknown Gender History: Sadie McMullen, 17-Year-Old Murderess – Akron, New York, 1890.” Unknown Gender History, November 15, 2015. http://unknownmisandry.blogspot.com/2015/11/sadie-mcmullen-17-year-old-murderess.html.
“GenealogyBank.Com - The Largest Newspaper Archive for Family History Research.” Accessed September 16, 2026. https://www.genealogybank.com/doc/census/image/v2%3A16DABE9A383D710A%40GB3CENSUS-16DABD5E1C30F310%402418673-16F9E86D94C4EE2D%40.
“John Dolph (1781-1834) - Find A Grave Memorial.” Accessed November 23, 2020. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/179636329/john-dolph.
“Legend of Murder Creek in Akron, New York - The Tragedy of Ah-Weh-Hah.” Accessed November 14, 2020. https://www.zeph1.com/2016/09/legend-murder-creek-akron-ny.html.
Map of Township 12 Range 5. c 1815. https://nyheritage.contentdm.oclc.org/digital/collection/XFM001/id/366/rec/5.
Moses, Jamie. “Murder Creek: The Sorry Case of Sadie McMullen.” Artvoice, October 27, 2016. https://artvoice.com/2016/10/27/murder-creek-sorry-case-sadie-mcmullen/.
Parker, Arthur Caswell. The Life of General Ely S. Parker : Last Grand Sachem of the Iroquois and General Grant’s Military Secretary. With University of California Libraries. Buffalo, N.Y. : Buffalo Historical Society, 1919. http://archive.org/details/lifeofgeneralely00parkrich.
Portland Daily Press (Portland, Maine). “She Killed Two Children: Was Committed to a Hospital as Insane and Is Now Liberated and Cured.” August 22, 1893. Tuesday Morning Edition.
Republican Advocate (Batavia, New York). “Notice to Trespsassers [Sic].” February 22, 1812.
“Sarah Dilley Dolph (1783-1861) - Find A Grave...” Accessed November 23, 2020. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/127942807/sarah-dolph.
Schrock, Fred. “The Legend of Murder Creek.” Low Bridges: Upstate History, October 31, 2014. https://fredschrock.com/2014/10/31/the-legend-of-murder-creek/.
The Buffalo Enquirer (Buffalo, New York). “She Is Sane!” August 19, 1893.
The Buffalo News (Buffalo, New York). “Acquitted! Jury Decides That Sadie McMullen Is Innocent of Crime.” March 7, 1891.
The Buffalo News (Buffalo, New York). “Queer Human Beings.” October 23, 1898.
The Buffalo Times (Buffalo, New York). “Her Love. The Secret of Sadie McMullen’s Hideous Crime.” November 4, 1890.
The Buffalo Times (Buffalo, New York). “Insanity. That Is the Burden of the McMullen Defense.” March 6, 1891.
The Evening Star (Washington, D.C.). “A Girl’s Trial for Murder.” March 6, 1891.
The Evening World (New York, New York). “Sadie M’Mullen Is Insane.” March 7, 1891.
“The Legend Of Murder Creek | Erie County Parks, Recreation and Forestry.” Accessed November 14, 2020. https://www2.erie.gov/parks/index.php?q=legend-murder-creek.
The World (New York, New York). “On Trial for Her Life.” March 6, 1891.
