Liked by Everyone, Chosen by No One: The Nice Guy Trap

A lot of gay men pride themselves on being “nice”— easygoing, agreeable, low-drama. But what if that’s exactly why you’re not getting what you want?

In this episode, we break down the difference between being kind and being “nice,” and how approval-seeking, conflict avoidance, and over-accommodating are quietly killing attraction, respect, and real connection. 

We talk about:

• Why “nice” is often a strategy, not a personality
• The hidden cost of being liked by everyone
• How this shows up in dating and relationships
• The difference between being chosen vs. being liked
• How to shift from approval-seeking to self-respecting

If you’ve ever felt overlooked, under-appreciated, or stuck in the friend-zone, this one will hit.

Today's Hosts:

• Matt Landsiedel
• Michael DiIorio - Take the 360° Self-Review for Gay Men
• Reno Johnston

Support the Show - viewer and listener support helps us to continue making episodes

- CONNECT WITH US -

• Watch podcast episodes on YouTube
• Join the Gay Men's Brotherhood Facebook community
• Get on our email list to get access to our monthly Zoom calls
• Follow us on Instagram | TikTok
• Learn more about our community at GayMenGoingDeeper.com

- LEARN WITH US -

• Building Better Relationships online course: Learn how to nurture more meaningful and authentic connections with yourself and others.
• Healing Your Shame online course: Begin the journey toward greater confidence and self-worth by learning how to recognize and deal with toxic shame.
• Gay Men Going Deeper Coaching Collection: Lifetime access to BOTH courses + 45 coaching videos and 2 workshop series.
• Take the Attachment Style Quiz to determine your attachment style and get a free report.

Chapters

• (00:00:00) - Gay Men Going Deeper: The Nice Guy Trap
• (00:01:04) - Being Nice
• (00:03:16) - What Does Being A Nice Guy Actually Mean To You?
• (00:05:46) - Matt on Being A Nice Guy
• (00:09:49) - Have You Ever Been The Nice Guy?
• (00:13:30) - Is Your Friend Think You're A Nice Guy?
• (00:17:16) - What Is Niceness In Your Relationships?
• (00:20:09) - Gayman's Brotherhood: Connection Circles
• (00:20:54) - Why Being a Nice Guy Backfires in Dating
• (00:23:16) - Matt Says Being Honest In Dating Backfires
• (00:28:19) - In the Elevator With Michael
• (00:29:38) - Gay Men on Dating and Relationships
• (00:30:19) - How to Shift From Being Nice to Being Chosen
• (00:35:02) - How To Be With Yourself
• (00:39:06) - Be Candid With Yourself
• (00:42:15) - Michael Jackson on Not Being Like Everyone
• (00:45:34) - Matt on Not Being the Nice Guy
• (00:48:20) - Thank You!