Gayer Than Originally Anticipated: Follow-up Interview with Jenna Dewitt - Sapphic, Aromantic, Asexual & Christian

EDJ and Jenna Dewitt sit down for a follow-up conversation about where Jenna has gone and grown since her interview with Jess and Devi in 2021. Jenna shares her journey as an aromantic, asexual, sapphic and celibate Christian, offering a fresh perspective on faith, identity, and belonging.

Together, we unpack the often-misunderstood experiences of aromantic and asexual people, challenge assumptions shaped by purity culture, and explore what it means to build truly inclusive faith communities.

Jenna explains the differences between aromantic and asexual identities, the meaning and history of the term sapphic, and why representation matters for people whose experiences are often overlooked—even within LGBTQIA+ spaces. She also reflects on her personal journey through evangelical Christianity, deconstruction, and discovering a more expansive, justice-centered faith.

Whether you're navigating your own spiritual journey, queer identity, supporting LGBTQIA+ loved ones, or simply curious about the intersection of faith and sexual identity, this conversation offers wisdom, compassion, and hope for a more inclusive future.

In This Episode

• What aromantic and asexual identities really mean—and the myths that surround them
• Why the term sapphic is broader than many people realize
• Jenna's story of faith, deconstruction, and embracing her identity
• Celibacy as a gift of freedom rather than a requirement
• How purity culture shapes our understanding of love, relationships, and sexuality
• Deconstruction can become a pathway to deeper, more authentic spirituality and self-acceptance
• Why many churches struggle to include LGBTQIA+ people—and what can change
• The importance of affirming community, belonging, and authentic faith
• Collective liberation reminds us that justice and love are inseparable.
• The future of progressive Christianity & practical ways churches and individuals can create more welcoming spaces

Connect with Jenna:

www.InvisibleCakeSociety.com

https://substack.com/@jennadewitt

https://www.instagram.com/jennadewitt/