In this episode of the Anglotopia Podcast, Jonathan Thomas sits down with Jeremy Harte — folklorist, winner of the Catherine Briggs Folklore Award, curator of Bourne Hall Museum in Surrey, and author of Cloven Country: The Devil in the English Landscape and Travelers Through Time: A Gypsy History — to discuss his remarkable new book Treasures on Earth: Buried Wealth in the English Landscape, published by Reaktion Books. Jeremy has spent his career chasing the uncanny side of the English landscape, and in this book he has gathered hundreds of treasure legends together for the first time — organizing them not by region or date but by emotion: memory, ruin, strife, terror, failure, and longing. The result is one of the most original and quietly brilliant books on English folklore in years, and the conversation it generates is irresistible: Why did people surround buried gold with dragons, black hens, and demons? What does the moment a laborer on the River Ribble accidentally uncovered a Viking army's war chest have in common with Oak Island? Why is the folklore always cruelest at the very last minute? What is the real fantasy underneath the search for treasure — not gold, but escape, freedom, and the dream of never having to work again? And what does the figure of Mackenzie Crook's Detectorists, swinging their machines over Essex fields and dreaming of Saxon gold, tell us about the ancient human urge that these legends have always mapped?

Links

Takeaways

  1. Treasure legends are not really about gold. They are, as Jeremy Harte argues throughout, about the emotions that surround gold — longing, memory, failure, terror, and the fantasy of transformation. The stories survived because of what they did to the people who told and heard them, not because of any actual buried wealth.
  2. The Cuerdale Hoard — the largest Viking silver hoard ever found in Britain, unearthed by laborers straightening the River Ribble in the 1840s — is one of the most powerful examples of how real treasure finds retrospectively generate legends. Almost all treasure "traditions" that seem to predict a find are only recorded after the find is made.
  3. The classic Anglo-Saxon image of the dragon sitting on a barrow of gold — doing nothing but guarding it forever, sacrificing whatever life a dragon might have — is, Jeremy argues, an early cultural articulation of what happens when treasure takes over a human life. The same psychology drives Oak Island today.
  4. Treasure guardians shift with the centuries — dragons and giants give way to fairies, then to demons, then to ghosts — not randomly but in response to what each era finds believable. A legend must sit in the zone between "obviously true" and "obviously made up" to function: too real and it's history, too fantastic and it's a fairy tale.
  5. The dissolution of the monasteries did not immediately generate treasure legends. It took fifty to a hundred years for the trauma to work its way into folklore — appearing in ghost monks, ruined abbey atmosphere, and stories of gold thrown into ponds or bricked up in tunnels. Society, like individuals, needs time to process collective shock before it becomes story.
  6. Mary Parrish, a "brandy-loving London cunning woman," and Goodwin Wharton, the gullible aristocrat she led on a years-long quest for fairy gold — documented entirely from Wharton's own obsessive diary — are perhaps the most human pair in the book. Wharton was simultaneously a reasonably successful MP, raised money from syndicates, and organized diving bells off the Scottish coast for Armada treasure. Jeremy describes their relationship as "a con, but also a love story."
  7. The folk cruelty of treasure legends — the fortune always snatched away by one tiny mistake, a single word spoken, one black hair on a white ox — is not random. These stories circulated among communities who had not done well for themselves. The unkindness of fate felt true to their experience. The treasure was always just out of reach because that was always true.
  8. The real fantasy of treasure, Jeremy argues, is not wealth but escape — to become a gentleman, meaning someone visibly unencumbered by the need to work. The problem for many of the poor communities generating these legends was that even if they found a single coin, they could not spend it without someone asking where it came from.
  9. Less than 10% of records are digital — a parallel to archaeology, where the vast majority of objects are still in the ground. Metal detectorists and archaeologists have more in common than either entirely admits: both are animated by the same desire to find something and to validate themselves through the finding. The difference is in what they're willing to record and share.
  10. The book closes with the gardener at Wallingford who dug for buried treasure in his spare time until one day they found a fresh hole, his spade and gloves beside it, and the man himself was never seen again. Jeremy chose this image deliberately: "It was almost like, if I'd been giving a talk, it would have been time for me to wave bye-bye and disappear behind a curtain."

Soundbites

  1. "Treasure is so potent it doesn't have to exist to destabilize human life. Most of the hordes in the book will never be found because they were never there." — Jeremy on the central argument of the book.
  2. "You find an Iron Age gold coin and it was — if it had been anything else, it would have been archaeology. It was the gold that made that different emotive feeling. And I thought I ought to be exploring that a bit." — Jeremy on the moment in the dried-out lake that started it all.
  3. "Think about the Anglo-Saxon dragon. He does nothing but guard gold, and sacrifices whatever a dragon life would be to just sit there forever in the darkness on the treasure. I thought, yeah, there is a common theme here." — Jeremy on why Oak Island and the dragon barrow are the same story.
  4. "It has to be the kind of thing you can announce in the pub and there will be a lively discussion with people banging down their pints and going, well bits of it could be true. It has to sit in that zone — too real and it's just history, too fantastic and it's a fairy tale." — Jeremy on what makes a legend work.
  5. "Mary Parrish — we have an entirely one-sided record. Goodwin Wharton was the literary half of the partnership. He even organized diving bells to try to dig up the treasure of the Armada off the coast of Scotland. And at the same time he is a fairly successful MP making his way up in government. Leading me to wonder what secrets might possibly lie in the diaries of some of our present members." — Jeremy on the Mary Parrish and Goodwin Wharton story.
  6. "People telling stories about lost treasure — the poorer the community, the more likely they are to be doing it. There's a sense of the unkindness of fate. People who had mastered fate and done quite well for themselves were sitting in the other corner and not contacting the gentleman with the story." — Jeremy on why treasure legends cluster around poverty.
  7. "The dissolution of the monasteries is recorded historically, basically day by day. What happened to the stuff is pretty well recorded. But it's not until well into the seventeenth century that you get the tropes of the monastic ghost, the buried treasures, the ghost monks. It took fifty to a hundred years for the trauma to work its way into folklore." — Jeremy on how collective trauma becomes legend.
  8. "The fantasy is to become a gentleman. Gentlemen are conspicuously visible in the countryside as people who wander around having no apparent need to work at anything whatsoever. Which of course is why they can go around collecting folk tales." — Jeremy on the real dream underneath treasure hunting.
  9. "When I actually go on site, my skepticism rolls away after about five miles walking. And I'm like, ooh, let's just have a quick look underneath here. There's a patch of dirt here. Let's just check. And I thought it'd be terribly embarrassing if I did actually find a hoard of gold. It's like — yeah, publicity exercise." — Jeremy's most English answer to whether he believes any treasure is really out there.
  10. "He'd disappeared and it was almost like, if I'd been giving a talk, it would have been time for me to wave bye-bye and disappear behind a curtain and go out the back." — Jeremy on why he ended the book with the vanishing gardener of Wallingford.

Chapters

  • 00:21 Introduction — Jonathan sets the scene and introduces Jeremy Harte and Treasures on Earth
  • 01:51 How Jeremy Came to Folklore — Thirty-five years at Bourne Hall Museum and the Iron Age gold coin that arrived in a little package
  • 03:17 From the Devil to Buried Treasure — The Hampstead Heath lockdown walk that crystallized the book
  • 05:11 Treasure Is So Potent It Doesn't Have to Exist — The central argument of the book
  • 06:17 Organizing by Emotion — Why memory, ruin, strife, terror, and failure work better than region or date
  • 08:33 Real Treasures and the Legends They Generated — The Cuerdale Hoard, the Rillaton Cup, and George V's toothbrush
  • 10:19 Memory Doing Something Creative After the Fact — Why traditions almost always appear after the find
  • 12:28 Comedy in Folklore — The shepherd who wrings every cockerel's neck and how humor functions in local legend
  • 13:56 Dragons, Demons, and Elaborate Spells — Why the imagination surrounds gold with monsters
  • 16:04 The Little Black Hen — Humble, absurd, and utterly unbeatable guardians
  • 17:17 Fairies and Treasure — Tricked out of it again and again, stones restored overnight, the ground healed over
  • 18:33 The Cast Changes Over the Centuries — Dragons, giants, fairies, demons, ghosts, and what the turnover tells us about belief
  • 20:52 Historical Trauma and Treasure Lore — The dissolution of the monasteries and the fifty-year delay before it became folklore
  • 23:17 Ghost Money — White ladies, restless spirits, and the gold that keeps the dead from resting
  • 24:42 The Failure Chapter — One tiny mistake, a single word, a curse, a black hair on a white ox's back
  • 25:45 Curses as Insurance Policies — The Worwell horde, the rector who applied to the Home Office, and why curses are rarer than fatal obstacles
  • 27:37 Who Were the Real Treasure Seekers? — Magical syndicates, single obsessives, and the communities that generated these stories
  • 29:05 Mary Parrish and Goodwin Wharton — A con, a love story, a diving bell off the Scottish coast, and an MP's extraordinary diary
  • 31:14 The Village Talking, Not the Diggers — Why most stories survive through gossip, not testimony
  • 32:44 Prophetic Treasure — Golden stags and civic generosity vs. London greed
  • 35:19 The Real Fantasy — Not gold, but escape; not wealth, but becoming a gentleman
  • 36:09 The Gardener of Wallingford — A spade, a glove, an empty hole, and the perfect last image
  • 36:56 Metal Detectorists as Heirs to the Tradition — The same longing, the same self-validation, new technology
  • 39:16 Detectorists — Mackenzie Crook, Andy and Lance, and why the yearning matters more than the find
  • 40:36 "The Real Treasure Is the Friends You Make Along the Way" — And the ones you lose when the magic goes wrong
  • 41:16 Magicians Who Moved On — The two kinds of cunning folk and how charisma covers an inability to find gold
  • 41:17 Final Question — Jeremy's favorite story, and whether he believes any of the treasure is really out there
  • 43:34 Wrap-Up — Treasures on Earth from Reaktion Books, links in show notes

Video Version

Rss Apple Podcaster
Podden och tillhörande omslagsbild på den här sidan tillhör Anglotopia LLC. Innehållet i podden är skapat av Anglotopia LLC och inte av, eller tillsammans med, Poddtoppen.