Nigel Farage’s latest scandal and Andy Burnham’s six-week report card dominate this PRmoment News Review, as Ben Smith quizzes Angie Moxham and Mark Borkowski on what the fallout means for UK politics and political communications.
Here are some quotes from this week's show:
"We woke up to the classic investigating journalist scam of trapping Nigel Farage and his two closest aides in a pub garden in Clacton-on-Sea." Mark Borkowski 0:01:10
"It's an absolute blow to Farage and the Reform Party, isn't it? I thought it was a long time coming. His riding of the tide of favour has now completely waned."
– Angie Moxham 0:03:29
"I think Farage had his moment, and I think it's gone. He'll put up a good fight for sure – he's a fighter – but I don't think he can really come back now from this." – Angie Moxham 0:04:49
"Farage is Trump-like. He plays to the front line of running straight on. He's spun it that this is just a climate activist stunt, and he has a sort of rhino Teflon coating that repels a lot of this stuff." – Mark Borkowski 0:05:17
"You do feel to a certain extent that Reform is a one man and a horse sort of party, and for many who wanted to join this new party, seeing some of the old Tory throwaways isn’t something they want to see." – Mark Borkowski 0:05:17
"The last few months, the damage to the Reform Party has been significant, and when we're living through a continued cost of living crisis, the general public are just looking at the pounds, shillings, and pence and thinking, ‘what the actual?’" – Mark Borkowski 0:05:17
On Andy Burnham:
"I think he's doing really well. I think he's still a bit starstruck – slightly shocked that he's in this position – but I think the guy's an honest player and he's doing a good job." – Angie Moxham 0:09:11
The episode opens with the Channel 4 sting on Reform UK’s funding. Borkowski sketches the scene of Farage and his aides being covertly filmed in a pub garden in Clacton-on-Sea, courted by a fake donor operation designed to funnel foreign money into the party via a resident son.
“We woke up to the classic investigating journalist scam of having a night trapping Nigel Farage and his two closest aides in a pub garden in Clacton-on-Sea,” he says 0:01:10. The alleged £200,000 offer, and Farage’s apparent enthusiasm for it, throws the “brown paper envelope” question of political donations back into the spotlight.
Angie Moxham is unequivocal. “Oh, it’s incredibly damning. But I’m not surprised." Adding that in modern politics, any underhand behaviour will be found out sooner or later 0:03:29. For her, this feels terminal for Farage’s recent momentum: “I think Farage had his moment, and I think it’s gone. He’ll put up a good fight for sure – he’s a fighter – but I don’t think he can really come back now from this” 0:04:49.
Borkowski is less willing to write him off. He frames Farage as structurally similar to Trump in his communications armoury. “Farage is Trump-like. He plays to the front line of running straight on… he has a sort of rhino Teflon sort of coating that repels a lot of this stuff” 0:05:17. Reform, he argues, is “a one man and a horse sort of party” drawing in the disillusioned fringes of the right, many of whom are tired of the “wokeiness” of mainstream politics 0:05:17. The party may be badly damaged, but Farage as a communicator is far from finished.
Both guests tie the scandal to the broader cost of living mood. Borkowski notes that “the last few months, the damage to the Reform Party has been significant,” and in a cost of living crisis, voters are simply looking at “the pounds, shillings, and pence” and thinking “what the actual?” 0:05:17. That economic anxiety becomes the bridge into Burnham’s early days in Downing Street.
Moxham gives Burnham an upbeat if cautious review. She sees an honest, pragmatic communicator who is still slightly stunned by his elevation. “I think he’s still a bit starstruck – slightly shocked that he’s in this position – but I think the guy’s an honest player and he’s doing a good job” 0:09:11. His highly visible social media presence, guitar-playing and “man of the people” persona may eventually grate, she concedes, but for now he’s broadly cutting through.
Borkowski stresses that Burnham’s real test will come with events beyond his control – from bond markets to Putin. “Any prime minister is challenged by events, events, events. It’s how he manages events at home and abroad that will show whether he’s more than this mayoral prime minister” 0:11:11. Six weeks in, the communications story is still in its honeymoon phase. The real narrative will be written by the winter ahead.
Support the show
