A Little Less Mess: Blood Under the Crabapple Tree [New Jersey]

Grab your mason jars and pull up a rocker as Cara steps outside the South for a solo trip back to the autumn of 1922. In an overgrown lovers’ lane outside New Brunswick, New Jersey, the bodies of an aristocratic Episcopal priest and his married choir leader were found staged beneath a crabapple tree, surrounded by their torn-up secret love letters and a grotesque calling card.

What followed became the country's first true media circus. From a high-society widow with millions on the line to an eccentric witness known as the "Pig Woman" testifying from a hospital bed wheeled into the courtroom, this century-old double homicide remains one of the most scandalous, theatrical, and baffling unsolved mysteries in American history. 

Find us on the webs!
Follow us on Instagram
Like us on Facebook
TikTok - @blessthismesspodcast
Support us on Patreon - for early access, ad-free, and Porch Crew perks!
Buy us a Coffee! - one time support to keep the porch lights on
Rate, Review, and Subscribe on Apple Podcasts or where you listen!
Music courtesy of Blanche

Sources 
- The Hall-Mills Murder Case (Historical Trial Transcripts & New Jersey State Police Archives)
- The New York Times, Contemporary Investigative Archives (1922–1926)
- New York Daily Mirror, Grand Jury & Somerville Court Coverage
- William Kunstler, *The Minister and the Choir Singer: The Hall-Mills Murder Case (William Morrow & Co.)