The Information State: Politics in the Age of Total Control with Jacob Siegel

Jacob Siegel is author of The Information State: Politics in the Age of Total Control. We discuss his thesis that the U.S. has shifted into a new form of governance where digital protocols and data infrastructures have displaced traditional legal and institutional sovereignty. Drawing on his experience as a U.S. Army intelligence officer who used Palantir in Afghanistan, Siegel describes what he calls the "paradox of information": these systems appear omnipotent but routinely fail to deliver their intended political outcomes, as illustrated by Vietnam, Russiagate, and the Biden-era censorship apparatus. The conversation covers Palantir's seductive but misleading graphical interfaces, why progressive/positivist epistemology is structurally predisposed to information control, AI's dual trajectory toward both planetary-scale power consolidation and intimate personal influence, Elon Musk's DOGE initiative and the possibility it served as a data-harvesting operation for Grok, the Anthropic-Pentagon standoff, Tablet Magazine's editorial model, AI's role in professional writing, and the removal of a positive review of Siegel's book from The Baffler following apparent pressure from disinformation researcher Renée DiResta.

The Information State: Politics in the Age of Total Control by Jacob Siegel
- Order from Amazon
- Order from a local bookshop

0:00 Intro
2:11 Vietnam as the laboratory for surveillance and automation
4:23 Does Palantir actually work?
10:38 Will AI tip the scales toward/against government control?
13:29 Why progressivism is predisposed to information control
17:27 Anthropic vs. Hegseth, Grok and the government
20:11 Planetary capture: AI as a winner-take-all competition
22:19 AI will re-personalize technology
23:06 Why DOGE failed
27:30 Crypto and Andreessen on Rogan
30:15 The overreach-backlash-entrenchment cycle
36:34 What makes Tablet Magazine work
40:10 AI and professional writing
46:42 The Baffler pulls a positive review of the book
53:56 Clint Watts and the revolving door
59:15 Closing thoughts