What’s a Good Click Rate? Measuring Email Success in 2025

Episode Summary:

What’s a good email open rate? What about click rates? Are your stats actually bad — or are you just comparing yourself to the wrong benchmarks? In this episode, I’m diving into email marketing stats for 2025 — what’s working for content creators, what’s realistic to expect, and how to know if your numbers are actually performing well. Here’s the thing: most creators assume they’re underperforming — but that’s often based on feelings, not facts. I’ll walk you through real industry benchmarks (yes, I did the research for you 🤓) AND share insider data from some of our Duett client projects — including specific numbers for welcome sequences, nurture emails, and newsletters that you won’t find anywhere else! If you’ve ever wondered whether your email stats are “good enough” — this episode will give you the clarity and confidence to measure your own success the right way.

In this episode, you’ll learn about:

• Why industry benchmarks are helpful — but also why they might not apply to your audience (and what to measure instead)
• Why welcome sequences perform differently than weekly newsletters
• A type of email layout that tends to get more clicks for bloggers (can you guess what it is?!)
• The deeply overlooked stats that have a HUGE impact on your overall site traffic and revenue
• Why focusing on total clicks might be more worth your time than focusing only on your click-through rate

Check out this episode's blog post 

Episode Resources:

Goals & Growth Tracker

Coaching Programs & Services:

Maximize Your Marketing - For those who need an in-house CMO (Chief Marketing Officer) to help you build sustainable email and promotional strategies, engage your subscribers, and grow your business and bottom line that otherwise is untapped potential.

The Duett Debut - Done for you email copywrting & automation setup 

Ready, Set, EMAIL - Quick & custom email setup to grow and send your newsletter fast

Book a FREE Discovery Call 

Instagram @alleagrummert